Is it OK to Stretch or Shrink an Existing Boat Design?

A bit of a hobbyhorse here.

The picture right is of my Goat Island Skiff (GIS) design. A nice, quick sailing, spacious, but easy to build sailing skiff. People tend to think it looks pretty nice too.

A fellow who built one of the GISs wanted to shrink the boat because of limited building space and that someone gave the poor fellow the advice that …

“Generally it is OK to shrink a boat by a factor of 10 or 15%”

So my customer went ahead only to find out that this is really, REALLY bad advice.

Also the sailmaker changed the sailplan a bit – but didn’t bother to decrease the sail area for the much shorter and less stable boat.

The poor builder had a terrible time trying to make the boat work.

In the end I reviewed the situation and made some relatively simple suggestions about getting it all to work OK.

Just a bit too frequently lately I’ve read various postings on the net along the line of:

“Generally it is OK to increase or decrease the length of a boat by 10 or 15%”

It is bad advice for a motor boat and really, really bad advice for a sailing boat.

How does the person making the claim know how close the designer has gone to the limit on a particular boat? And will that line be crossed with the change.

Also are they allowing for the different relationships of the parts as in a sailing boat. Centres of effort, gravity, buoyancy, lateral resistance.

Do they know that by reducing the size of a boat by 15% all round the stability is reduced to 50% of the original?

So I’ve added three things to my webpage.

1/ A preamble to the problem
2/ An actual case study of someone who built one of my Goat Island Skiff (GIS) designs but changed a number of things because someone advised that it is “an OK” thing to do.
3/ Some advice about how to make the changes more safely in some boats.

The articles are here on my FAQ article

Some experts deserve a big kick up the bum.

And that is the end of my rant!

Related Post

Big Update to the Boatbuilding and Epoxy FAQ (includes some canoe stuf... Yep, Just spent a good three hours whipping up another 14 pages for my website. Mostly additions to my epoxy, boatbuilding and boat design FAQ ...
Second interview up on The first part was up last week.This week we talk about traditional vs modern sailtypes - everyone knows I am a fan of trad rigs because of their low ...
New Peak Speed Record in PD Racer class held by OzRacer. The world speed record for PDRacers is currently 6.5mph. During the recent South Australian Wooden Boat Festival (pic of three of our five PDRS on th...
Wooden Boat Building – 10 day Autumn Class Duck Flat Wooden Boats in conjunction with Michael Storer Wooden Boat Plans will be running a 10 day boat building Autumn School.April 16 to 26th at G...
Are old, cheaper or free boat plans good value? 100 plans on CD? A question was asked about Hartley Designs.  The answer applies to the general discussion about what has changed in plans and designs over the last 50...
“Disposable” Canoeing – building a canoe in a few ho... Quick Canoe plan information UPDATE -The numbers are growing - one took 4.5 hours to build, two other builds took 5.5 hours.  Others have taken a w...

Leave a Reply